Quantcast
Reviews

Watching Water on a pirated DVD

By Editorial Team • Published on February 2, 2007

Amidst the all pervading jubilant mood around water making it to the Oscars final, my DVD wallah is busy selling more and more pirated copies. However, a vague memory of political right’s anger against the “misrepresentation” of the great Indian culture held me from even daring to think of the possibility of getting a pirated copy. Also a semi-idealist stance that a producer-filmmaker have a right to earn from the film they produce discouraged me to watch the film before it gets released in theatres, though my idealism lasted as long as I failed to manage a copy.

I got confused about what comes first, respect for the law of the land or an enthusiast’s impatience or a producer’s right to earn from the film. And as usual the benefit of doubt went in favor of the enthusiast.

Water recreates an entire era from the fringes. A widow ashram, quite unaware of the waves of changes that are sweeping across the British India. Bogged down in the gradually rotting sense of respect for the tradition. The sacred river Ganga separates this world from the other, where Gandhian thoughts have just arrived (read John Abraham). Gulabo, the eunuch pimp tries her best to update the ashram’s didi on Gandhian revolution that has caught imagination of the world outside but not to mention from behind the window. The two worlds separated by iron bars. Gulabo keeps bringing news of Gandhi and his weird ideas and Madhumati didi pokes fun at them.

The beautiful Lisa Ray, the only widow with long hair (Sprite effect-joking, to be cut later), meets the Gandhian John Abraham. John recites Kalidas’s Meghdootam to her in Sanskrit. They fall in love.

Water is cinematographed beautifully and it has haunting background score. The film is graced with a rare lyrical quality that creates an epical feel.

Water begins beautifully. Silently it introduces us to little chirpy eight years old Chuiya whose husband is terminally ill. He dies and Chuiya is informed – do you remember getting married, now you’re a widow.

Chuiya is left at a widow ashram in Benaras to spend rest of her life. Since then the only wish that keeps her going is to go back home. Little actress Sarala renders a brilliant performance as Chuiya.

While this part of the word is caught up with daily routine, Gandhi is bringing in a revolution elsewhere. His revolutionary ideas of equality and downtrodden being Harijan, the people of the God, is poked fun at by ashram didi.

Deepa Mehta builds quite a cinematic climax. History in making is to pass by this otherwise sleepy town. And it will stop there for only five minutes. Gandhi is received by a deluge of people. Chuiya succeeds to catch the Gandhian train. Words hang in the air “give her to Gandhi”

Film has brilliant performances. Right from little Sarala to Raghuveer yadav and Manorama. Yes we could have expected more from John and Lisa both.

Water is a brilliant film that deserves all the awards. It has a unique distinction of a film on Indian theme not even shot in India. It speaks volumes of the political transformation underway.

Did you like reading this article?

Get DearCinema in your Inbox

Or grab the RSS feed!

Editor's Pick

Ashim Ahluwalia debunks 12 rules of filmmaking
The maverick director of John and Jane and Miss Lovely shared his insight on ...
DearCinema brings out funding and markets guide for indie filmmakers
DearCinema has brought out a handbook for Indian independent filmmakers who are looking ...
Aditya Vikram Sengupta wins Best Debut Director award at Venice Days
Aditya Vikram SenGupta was named the Best director of a debut film for Bengali film ...
Chaitanya Tamhane talks about”Court” that won two awards in Venice
Mumbai-based filmmaker Chaitanya Tamhane’s debut feature film Court recently had a ...

Join the discussion

2 Responses to “Watching Water on a pirated DVD”

  1. Anonymous says:

    bikas you have put it so brilliantly that first think i want to do tomorrow morning is to watch the film…

  2. iram says:

    Arre yaar… I recently attended the launch of Creative Commons – India chapter at IIT – B and the star speaker – atleast for me – was none other than Anurag Kashyap – who took a pro- ‘piracy’ stance. I cant understand your anxiety regarding a pirated DVD. Would you have ever managed to watch the films you have watched, read the text books you have read – if it were not for these ‘illegal’ copies? ;-)
    Oh and I’ve have yet to see Water…

Leave a Reply