Mixed Reviews for “Bombay Talkies” at Cannes

By NewsDesk • Published on May 23, 2013

Bombay Talkies PosterBombay Talkies, an omnibus film directed by Karan Johar, Dibakar Banerjee, Zoya Akhtar and Anurag Kashyap has received mixed reviews after its gala screening at Cannes.

Screen International’s Tim Grierson writes, “A consistent charmer, the Indian omnibus Bombay Talkies is vibrant and colourful, that rare portmanteau film where the whole is more than the sum of its likeable parts.”

On the other hand, The Hollywood Reporter’s Deborah Young writes, “Maybe the most impressive thing about this uneven film is its interminable end credits, which give audiences a clue about the manpower that goes into making Hindi films today.”

An excerpt from Screen Review:

Arguably, Bombay Talkies’ strongest international value will be in showing outsiders that contemporary Indian cinema doesn’t entirely consist of song-and-dance musicals. While there are fun pop tunes included on the soundtrack, only the first short feels overly dependent on music to enhance its story. (Akhtar’s short also incorporates music, but in a really fun way.) And there are several fine performances, especially Siddiqui as the father thrust into the spotlight and Jain as the boy longing to become a dancer. To be sure, Bombay Talkies is a breezy, unsubstantial work. But when a film is this effervescent, who needs all that stuffy substance?

An excerpt from Hollywood Reporter Review:

Launched at a gala red carpet screening at Cannes, the four stories of Bombay Talkies are meant to celebrate the one hundred years of Indian cinema but do very little to further its reputation….They are of varying interest, but the overall impression they leave is watching a Bollywood sampler without the song and dance, a committee project with an impressive budget but little heart.


Cannes Review: Ritesh Batra’s Lunchbox

Cannes Review: Amit Kumar’s Monsoon Shootout

Cannes Review: Anurag Kashyap’s Ugly

Tagged with: , , , , , , ,

Did you like reading this article?

Get DearCinema in your Inbox

Or grab the RSS feed!

Editor's Pick

Uncertainty over Mumbai Film Festival, supporters take to social media
Uncertainty looms large over 16th Mumbai Film Festival that is scheduled to take place ...
Why touts thrive in censor board office
An Independent filmmaker's first hand account of getting a censor certificate in ...
Why short filmmakers need to be more professional in their approach
Short-films are the blind spot for the contemporary tribe of film commentators, ...
Why Cinelicious Pics acquired Gangs of Wasseypur for North America
Dennis Bartok, who set up Cinelicious Pics with film restoration expert Paul Korver in ...

Join the discussion

2 Responses to “Mixed Reviews for “Bombay Talkies” at Cannes”

  1. Sohil Nikam says:

    How would they understand the incomprehensible impact that cinema has had on us throughout these hundred years? Just doesn't matter what they think.

  2. I think Indian popular cinema is so dependent on one of those: vulgar item songs '

Leave a Reply